The business platform for digital media

Industry Insights: The Independent ditches print

Feb 18, 2016
Industry trends

It came as a surprise last week when the owner of the London quality daily, The Independent, announced he was shuttering the paper’s presses and going fully digital. Given the loss of print advertising revenue, declining subscriptions and sinking CPMs, is this really so shocking? Digital is cheaper to produce, there is no paper, no ink; there are no printing presses, no delivery trucks. By dumping print the Indy extends its opportunity to produce quality journalism and if you compare journalism to music, it make sense (from vinyl to MP3s). Let’s hope the Lebedevs are true to their word, reinvest the money they receive from the sale of the Indy’s sister paper i, back into the digital Independent.

Read more about what publishers are discovering  in this week’s Industry Insights, available now!

Code Conference kicks off tomorrow, Piano attending!

Feb 16, 2016

Screen Shot 2016-02-16 at 11.29.01
We are excited that Piano’s Director of North American Sales & Business Development David Restrepo will be attending the code/media (#codemedia) conference, part of Vox Media’s re/code events, in Dana Point, CA starting tomorrow! This is an incredible conference with a lot of top media executives in attendance and plenty of interesting industry learnings to be shared. We  welcome the opportunity to meet any of you who are also going. If you are interested in setting up a meeting with David, please send him an email.

Lessons in paid content III: Don’t just slap a meter on it

This is another in a series of articles from Piano’s Lead Data Scientist Roman Gavuliak that were written last year and are being re-posted here for the edification of our faithful readers.

Lessons in Paid Content I: Not all content is created equal
Lessons in Paid Content II: The size of your audience
To read all of Roman’s articles please click here.

Our last post looked at the size of a target audience for a typical publishing site with 2 million monthly unique users as reported by Google Analytics. After accounting for Google’s user overestimation and users that only skim headlines, there were between 0.5M – 0.7M monthly readers left. Now, assume the example publisher’s online team decides to implement a meter limit of 10 articles per month; one that mirrors the current New York Times limit. What follows is the monthly content consumption for users in our example (based on similar real newspapers):

Screen Shot 2016-02-16 at 10.51.20
The graph shows that the share of users reading more than 10 articles (10+ category) is below 10%. This is not uncommon for many titles and means a metered paywall with a setting of 10 free articles per month affects (building on the example) between 40k – 60k users, users who can be effectively monetized. This doesn’t mean a metered paywall makes no sense, it means there must be realistic expectations about its impact.

This curve allows for optimizing paywall impact, regrettably it lacks a sweet spot where there is an optimal trade-off between pageview and user impact. However, the sweet spot doesn’t exist because article pageviews follow roughly a 80/20 rule (80% of article pageviews are done by 20% of users) and, changes impacting pageviews are really much smaller when compared to changes in terms of affected audience. Therefore there is an inherent risk associated with implementing a metered paywall with any setting.

However, there is a big upside – a more aggressive approach brings more opportunity. To wit: numbers from metered paywall estimation are presented in the following table:

Screen Shot 2016-02-16 at 10.36.26
The conclusion here is: don’t be scared!

The percentage of affected pageviews is only on articles. A metered paywall leaves homepages and section fronts freely accessible. The resulting percentage loss of pageviews from all pageviews is lower and decreases further based on the conversion rate (since the pageviews of paying users are retained and might even grow as these users now attribute a monetary value to the content they read).

Back to the example; lowering the meter setting from 10 to 4 free articles per month means increasing the absolute percentage pageview loss risk by 5.6% while almost doubling the absolute share of users affected (on all users reading articles). Keep in mind too, that people reading over 10 articles per month are more likely to pay than those reading only five articles per month.

So what is the takeaway here? Ten free articles per month might sound like a nice round number and it works for New York Times; but while user distribution is based on their reading level and follows a similar mathematical function, it differs in parameters. These differences are illustrated in the graph below. One daily Estonian title has roughly 1M monthly unique visitors while a Slovak daily has 2M monthly visits and two German titles have 1.9M and 2.7M respectively.


Despite having the smallest audience, a limit of 10 free articles a month would impact the greatest share of users at the Estonian daily newspaper.

A metered paywall then, is not about the size of your site, but about understanding your audience and putting this knowledge into action.

Piano Sponsors first-ever Slovak MeasureCamp

Feb 12, 2016

MeasureCamp, to those in the know, is an “unconference” dedicated to data and analytics and has a worldwide following. Piano’s Lead Data Scientist Roman Gavuliak helped bring MeasureCamp to the Slovak Capital, Bratislava, last week so the burgeoning community of data analysts and scientists plus developers who rely data, could get together and share their experiences with each other and other interested parties.

All MeasureCamps start out chaotically as organizers and participants agree on a program, find rooms and kick off sessions. Piano wasn’t the only sponsor, Google and Telekom sponsored sessions as well. Many local Slovak marketing agencies and product developers from the best online dev shops shared their lessons learned, tools and processes and best practices. Roman led a session on various data sources and alternatives to the ubiquitous Google Analytics.

At the end of the day, when all the 30 minute sessions had expired, the Afterparty got swinging and, as those who are familiar with Slovak party habits, it wasn’t over until the wee hours of the morning.

MeasureCamp was a huge success and Piano was proud to sponsor this initial effort. The sessions were great for enlightening local developers, analysts, data scientists and will naturally contribute to improving the quality and utilization of data for software companies worldwide.

Since Piano is so heavily involved in big data and analytics, we were super excited to see the interest generated by the “unconference” and hope that there will be more Slovak MeasureCamps in the future.

You can read more on the Bratislava’s MeasureCamp Facebook page.


Industry Insights: Are micropayments the next big thing?

Feb 11, 2016
Industry trends

With the rise of ad blocking, more publishers are considering micropayments as an alternative revenue stream. However, the solution to the primary barrier that deterred publishers from micropayments previously, decision fatigue, has yet to be found. Readers already bothered by tracking software and invasive ads will not spend time deciding whether an individual article is worth paying for. Until digital wallets or some other paradigm defines an easy micropayment standard that eliminates constant decision making, micropayments remain a hopeful dream rather than a real revenue stream.

Read more about what publishers are discovering  in this week’s Industry Insights, available now!